Missoula
Advertisement Advertisement

NorthWestern Energy Merged on Monday. Now It's Headed to Court.

The PSC approved the $15.4 billion deal 3-2, the companies closed it on Monday, and the same day a petition asked a court to void the approval.

Zootown Lowdown Staff

Zootown Lowdown Staff

0 Comments
Zootown Lowdown graphic: This week in Missoula - NorthWestern merges, gets sued

Montana’s largest utility now has a new parent company. NorthWestern Energy, which says it serves gas and electric customers across the western two-thirds of Montana, completed its merger with South Dakota’s Black Hills Corp. on Monday, Nov. 16. The combined company is called Bright Horizon Energy.

 

The same day, two Montana groups went to court to try to undo it.

 

How it got approved

 

Montana’s Public Service Commission approved the $15.4 billion all-stock deal on Tuesday, Nov. 10, by a 3–2 vote, Montana Free Press reports. Commissioners Annie Bukacek, Kirk Bushman and Jennifer Fielder voted yes; Randy Pinocci and Jeff Welborn voted no. Montana was the last state regulator to decide.

 

Supporters argued a bigger utility can borrow more cheaply and cut costs. “This application does not raise rates,” Bushman said. Pinocci’s question for his colleagues was the one most bill-payers will recognize: “What are we going to do about lowering the rates for the people?”

 

Of the 35 people who spoke during public comment, most opposed the merger, citing rate increases and growing demand from data centers.

 

What changed on Monday

 

In their closing announcement, the companies said NorthWestern is now a wholly owned subsidiary of Bright Horizon, which is headquartered in Rapid City, South Dakota, and continues to do business as NorthWestern Energy. Brian Bird is president and chief executive.

 

For customers, the companies say there are no immediate changes to branding, how you pay, how you report an outage or how you reach customer service, according to the Daily Montanan. The merger itself does not change rates; any future increase would still have to go through a rate case at the PSC.

 

The court challenge

 

On Monday, 350 Montana and the Montana Farmers Union, represented by attorney Monica Tranel, filed a petition in Lewis and Clark County District Court asking a judge to declare the PSC’s order void and halt the deal. Their main arguments:

 

  • The PSC closed part of its Nov. 10 meeting, which the groups say broke the Montana Constitution’s open-meeting requirement.
  • The commission did not weigh the risk that Montana ratepayers could end up funding capital Bright Horizon has promised to AI data centers.
  • It did not properly evaluate the 370 megawatts of Colstrip power NorthWestern acquired from Puget Sound Energy — and the petition asks the court to block any sale or transfer of those shares.

 

Tranel argues the merger is not final while a 30-day reconsideration period runs. A PSC spokesperson said the commission had not been served and had no comment; NorthWestern said it does not comment on pending litigation. The company has said shareholders, not customers, will bear its $19.9 million in 2026 merger costs.

 

Why it matters here

 

The question underneath both the vote and the lawsuit is the same one Missoula County is wrestling with in its own data center rules: when a utility builds for very large new customers, who pays for it. Our coverage of the data center fight inside city limits.

 

Sources

 

0 Comments

Join the conversation

Be the first to comment

Share your thoughts above.

More from Zootown Lowdown

Zootown Lowdown

© 2026 Zootown Lowdown.

Zootown Lowdown brings Missoula to your inbox with a friendly mix of local news, stories, and happenings. From mountain trails to downtown coffee shops, we spotlight the people, places, and events that make Missoula such a special place to live. Whether you’re a lifelong local or a new neighbor, this newsletter keeps you plugged into the heart of Zootown.

© 2026 Zootown Lowdown.

This publication sponsored by